Roseanne's back - 'still feisty and funny' but 'not as good as the original' Skip to main content

Roseanne's back - 'still feisty and funny' but 'not as good as the original'

Roseanne castImage copyright ABC Image caption Roseanne and Dan have to adjust to having daughter Darlene and her children come to live with them

Revivals of much-loved TV series can be hit and miss. And Roseanne has been welcomed back by critics - but they say it doesn't quite match the original.

Many of the sitcom's stars are back 21 years on, including Roseanne Barr and John Goodman as Roseanne's husband Dan.

The New York Times said the show was still "feisty and funny" and likened it to the "old couch you can't throw out".

Vulture's Jen Chaney wrote: "It may not be quite as good or as groundbreaking as the original, but it holds up."

Image copyright ABC Image caption Sarah Chalke returns to play a different character this time around

The show originally ran from 1988 to 1997, and the reboot finds out how the working class Connor family are faring later in life during the Trump era.

Goodman's character was killed off in the last series, but somehow makes a miraculous return in series 10 and he and Roseanne are now grandparents.

Image copyright ABC Image caption Laurie Metcalfe and Roseanne Barr in a 1989 episode

Variety's critic Sonya Saraiya said the new episode, which airs in the US on Tuesday, was "a bit rough around the edges".

She continued: "The embrace of the past is both cosy and smothering, a musty-smelling throw intentionally full of holes that looks warmer than it is. No wonder Darlene (Sara Gilbert) fled to Chicago."

Dominic Patten, writing in Deadline, praised the "indomitable" scripts and the performances of Goodman and Gilbert.

But he added that, "with the glorious exception of Gilbert... most of the cast seem to be speed dialling in their performances".

Image copyright ABC Image caption Dan is back - despite dying of a heart attack in the series finale in 1997

He wrote: "As if this was a Roseanne tribute and not a reunion of the original band, eyelines and attention spans are all over the place as if looking for cue cards. Additionally, the pacing misses the beat repeatedly, and jokes are launched only to land far off target."

Another critic, David Bianculli, told NPR Radio: "As revived sitcoms from an earlier era go, Roseanne is a lot better than Netflix's Fuller House and a bit better than One Day At A Time.

"But that's not high praise, and it's not meant to be. When it premiered, Roseanne broke new ground. This time around, it's good, but nowhere near required viewing."

New York Times writer, James Poniewozik, was more generous. He wrote: "Roseanne is a revival that's willing to grapple with the time that's passed rather than deny it.

"It's feisty and funny and a little sad. And like that old couch you can't throw out, it may just have a good year or two left in it."

Image copyright Getty Images Image caption Roseanne Barr and John Goodman are back together

Speaking at the series premiere last week, Sarah Chalke, who played Becky from series six and now has a new role as surrogate mother Andrea, said the time was right to bring Roseanne back.

She said: "I think it is extremely relevant. I think that one of the strongest things about Roseanne in its first incarnation was Roseanne never shied away from any topic. She wanted to tackle them head-on, and that is absolutely the case in the new one.

"And I think it really looks at the challenges facing American families today - both the effect the (presidential) election had on families and it deals with surrogacy, and pill addiction and ageing and death and divorce."

Goodman said the cast reunion felt like "putting on an old shoe and running a couple of laps," while Barr described it as "same old thing".

Follow us on Facebook, on Twitter @BBCNewsEnts, or on Instagram at bbcnewsents. If you have a story suggestion email entertainment.news@bbc.co.uk.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Tueazee - I Know #Flyah Review

Tueazee is an exciting music group based in Augusta, GA, and they have been making music for about a year now.  Releasing music under the J Tizzle Muzic label, the group recently unveiled a new, exciting single titled “I Know.”The song is a great example of Tueazee’s pure and uncompromising combination of new and old-school hip-hop, making for a driven, direct and fast-paced feel that knows no compromises whatsoever. Their flow echoes the work of seminal performers such as Jay Z, Kendrick Lamar, Common or J Cole, bridging the gaps between the unmistakable tone of the 90s golden age and the modern feel.Ultimately, “I Know” stands out as a perfect combination of old-school hip-hop and modern punch, making for a striking, professional and world-class production value.

Piqued Jacks rock n roll #Flyah

Piqued Jacks describe their sound in their own words: “being able to speak without impediment; having sex in the most intense way possible; expressing ourselves 100%”. You have to hear it to experience it for yourself. Piqued Jacks are brave souls. Rising from a small village in Italy, they have methodically made their way from obscurity to Austin, the heart of the indie music scene, performing 2 showcases at SXSW 2013. Their powerful alliance and headstrong vision has resulted in rapid success and the positive flow of their career indicates a confident band gaining serious momentum. Back in 2006, the Piqued Jacks were anything but serious. They causally acquired the band name after someone drops a bass during rehearsal. The damaged jack resembled an erect penis and the boys felt the sexual allusion suited their sound. A few years later, something clicked, a unified connection to the music making process, and from 2010 to 2011 they released two EP’s, conquering Italian airw…

Alla P. Gakuba - A Person is a Product of Time Place and Circumstances

Alla P. Gakuba's short stories are lengthy and full of information whether from historical periods to relate to current times. The twenty short stories detail infamous events such as Napoleon's rise and fall to American women receiving rights to vote. Another of the short stories was about Maslow's Theory describing the five steps of life and achievements. This book is inspiring and gives insight into the mentality of many great people who contributed to society, helped others in times of need and become more self-aware. Alla talked about her time as a engineer being changed from constructing buildings to bridges with no guidance given to her. Even after transferring from Africa to U.S.A. for an engineering job, Alla was puzzled that she earned the job but she strive to achieve her goals. In life, dedication can be the breaking point of a successful venture and a reflection of the steps taken to get there. Alla also theorizes about a time that women felt uncomfortable in a …